New York’s U.S. Representative Maurice Hinchey represents an oddly-shaped district that twists from Poughkeepsie on the eastern shore of the Hudson River all the way along the border with Pennsylvania up to Ithaca, New York in the Finger Lakes. Yet, he represents his constituents well, defending the constitutional freedoms in which residents of his district place their trust.
On June 20, 2008, when so many other Democrats in the House of Representatives panicked and ran into the arms of the Republicans, voting for George W. Bush’s FISA Amendments Act, Congressman Hinchey kept his head. He voted against the FISA Amendments Act.
Hinchey explained,
“The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act has been in effect since 1978 and provided every president and his administration since that time with the tools and resources needed to effectively monitor the activities of those wishing to harm the United States. I recognize the need to modernize our surveillance laws and have been willing to make adjustments to improve them, but sacrificing our basic civil liberties and granting de facto immunity to telecommunication companies that may have violated the law to appease the Bush administration is simply unacceptable.
The United States government should have all the tools it needs to keep us safe, but we must recognize that we can definitely achieve that goal without sacrificing the defining principles of the Constitution. Privacy rights must not be compromised simply because this administration is trying to scare everyone into believing such actions are necessary.”
Maurice Hinchey is right. The government should have all the tools it needs to keep Americans safe, provided that those tools do not violate the Americans’ rights.
The FISA Amendments Act is not a necessary tool for America’s security, and it deprives Americans of freedoms that are essential to the survival of democracy in the USA. On both counts, Maurice Hinchey did the right thing in voting NO on the FISA Amendments Act.
Thanks to Maurice Hinchey for doing the right thing, and voting with his head instead of pandering to the politics of fear.